Coconut ice cream with fresh toasted coconut slivers, bites of Callebaut dark chocolate, and sliced almonds.
Apple á la Mode
Vanilla ice cream with a swirl of apple pie filling and crunchy bits of home-made streusel
Banana Nut Crunch
Banana ice cream made with fresh bananas and mixed with chopped walnuts and Heath toffee chunks.
Vanilla cake batter ice cream with rainbow sprinkles.
Black cherry ice cream with fresh chopped Bing cherries
There is no way to describe this flavor other than to taste it, but true Midwesterners will know that we make the real thing.
Tutti-frutti ice cream with tiny pieces of bubble gum mixed in.
Root beer flavored ice cream swirled with a thick ribbon of butterscotch.
Maple ice cream mixed with pecans that are hand toasted with a hint of brown sugar.
Vanilla ice cream with Butterfinger pieces.
Café con Leche
Vanilla ice cream infused with a rich cold-brew Columbian coffee and swirled with a sweet ribbon of condensed milk.
Candy Bar Crunch
Vanilla ice cream mixed with M&Ms, Heath Bar, Nestle Crunch, and rainbow sprinkles, with a thick fudge swirl throughout.
Butterscotch ice cream with butterscotch swirl, Oreo cookie pieces, Heath Bar Toffee chunks, and peanut butter cups.
Vanilla ice cream with a hint of cherry flavor, swirled with sweet cherry preserves, with crunchy pieces of homemade streusel mixed throughout.
Our chocolate ice cream is made with gourmet Forbes’ cocoa giving it a uniquely rich, creamy, and decadent flavor.
Chocolate ice cream with a hint of cherry flavor and a swirl of wild cherry preserves
Vanilla ice cream mixed with hand-chopped Callebaut milk chocolate pieces.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
Vanilla ice cream with chocolate chip cookie dough pieces and a fudge swirl throughout.
Chocolate ice cream with a hint of orange flavor.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Rush
Chocolate ice cream with a creamy ribbon of peanut butter
Chocolate ice cream mixed with hand-toasted pecans.
Columbian cold brew coffee infused ice cream with crunchy home-made toffee chunks.
Vanilla ice cream with Oreo pieces, chocolate chip cookie dough chunks, and a rich fudge swirl – and of course, it’s blue!
Cookies n’ Cream
Vanilla ice cream mixed with crunchy, delicious Oreo pieces.
Cotton candy flavored ice cream, swirled pink and blue.
Double Fudge Brownie
Dark chocolate ice cream made with Forbes’ cocoa and loaded with delicious chewy fudge brownie chunks.
Vanilla, cherry-berry, and blue moon swirled together for a patriotic treat.
Vanilla ice cream infused with the highest quality Madagascar vanilla beans.
Guava ice cream mixed with smooth bites of cheesecake.
Guava ice cream with strawberry preserve swirl.
Double fudge chocolate ice cream mixed with milk chocolate chips and almonds, and swirled with marshmallow fluff.
Vanilla ice cream swirled with a thick ribbon of smooth Nutella.
Key Lime Cheesecake
Key lime ice cream mixed with chunks of cheesecake.
Lemon ice cream with a blueberry preserve swirl made from wild Maine blueberries.
Mangos n’ Cream
Mango ice cream with fresh mango chunks
Mint Chocolate Chip
Fresh mint ice cream with chopped Belgian dark chocolate pieces.
Mint ice cream with Oreo cookie pieces.
Chocolate ice cream with mini marshmallows, Blommer’s gourmet chocolate chunks, peanut butter cups, and a ribbon of fudge.
Orange cream flavored ice cream reminiscent of the orange push-pops.
Peanut Butter Swirl
Vanilla ice cream with a ribbon of creamy peanut butter.
PeaNUTS about You
Peanut butter ice cream with a fudge swirl.
Mint ice cream with pieces of chocolate peppermint patties.
Chocolate ice cream with peanut butter cups and mini marshmallows.
Coconut ice cream with crushed pineapple mixed throughout.
Pistachio ice cream with toasted pistachio pieces
Pralines n’ Cream
Vanilla ice cream with chunks of home-made praline pieces.
French vanilla ice cream with a raspberry swirl and Blommer’s gourmet chocolate chunks
Chocolate ice cream with raspberry swirl
Chocolate ice cream with marshmallows, walnuts, and a rich fudge swirl
Root Beer Swirl
Vanilla ice cream and root beer ice cream swirled perfectly together
Salted Caramel Praline
Salted caramel ice cream with chunks of home-made pralines.
Salted Caramel Truffle
Salted caramel ice cream mixed with chocolate truffles filled with caramel inside.
Siesta Key Rum Raisin
Vanilla ice cream with raisins soaked in our local, award-winning, Siesta Key Spiced Rum
Vanilla ice cream with a swirl of strawberry preserves and cheesecake chunks.
Fresh strawberry and vanilla ice cream swirled together
Strawberry ice cream with a swirl of fresh strawberry preserves
Lemon, tutti frutti, and blue moon ice cream all mixed together in a uniquely midwestern flavor.
Coconut ice cream with shaved toasted coconut mixed in.
White Chocolate Chip
Chocolate ice cream with white chocolate chips
NO SUGAR ADDED
Black Cherry ice cream with fresh Bing Cherries
Caramel ice cream, no added sugar
Chocolate ice cream, no added sugar
Coffee ice cream, no added sugar
Mango ice cream with fresh Mango Chunks
Maple ice cream with walnut pieces, no added sugar
Peach ice cream, no added sugar
Raspberry ice cream, no added sugar
Vanilla ice cream, no added sugar
Guinness Dark Chocolate
Dark chocolate ice cream infused with Guinness beer
Mint ice cream with pieces of chopped peppermint bark mixed in
Pumpkin Spice Cheesecake
Pumpkin spice ice cream with chunks of cheesecake
Strawberry ice cream infused with a rose’ wine
MATEO'S ITALIAN ICE